Batman : A Death In The Family - "Jason Todd lives" (unpublished alternate comic book story, existence unconfirmed; 1988)


Batman: A Death in the Family -- "Jason Todd Lives"
"You decided his fate. Or did you?" A panel depicting Robin's demise.
"You decided his fate. Or did you?" A panel depicting Robin's demise.
Status Existence Unconfirmed
The page from Batman Annual.

In 1988, DC Comics made the controversial decision to kill off Batman's second Robin, Jason Todd, a character disliked by some fans as well as members of DC's creative staff.

To generate publicity and gauge fan sentiment, a 1-800 call-in line was established to decide Robin's fate. At the end of one of the issues, called A Death In The Family, callers were to whether or not the Joker managed to kill Jason Todd after a cliffhanger beating followed by an explosion. The fans allegedly decided that the Joker succeeded in killing Robin, but the legitimacy of the vote and the existence of an alternate outcome comic have been questioned.

Jason was a wilder, more rebellious Robin than Dick Grayson, which the fans and staff grew to dislike with time. In an infamous sequence in the 'A Death In The Family' storyline, the Joker beat Jason near to death with a crowbar, then blew up the room he was in. Batman arrived in time to see the explosion, and the comic ended, leaving the cliffhanger ending. The vote in question followed, and in the next issue, Jason was dead.

It has been claimed (and denied by DC from the start) that the vote was pure theater, and that Jason Todd was to die no matter what. While the vote's outcome was close (no outside vetting has been done, and now seems unlikely), Batman veteran writer Denny O'Neil has posited that this was due to some readers thinking they were voting on the fate of Dick Grayson, and that the vote absent this would have been heavily in favor of killing off Jason Todd. Others say that, wishing to nudge the outcome their way, DC staffers flooded the phone banks in favor of Jason's death. Whatever the truth of these rumors and speculation, DC may have ended up feeding this frenzy by how it has handled things since then.

The only evidence of an alternate comic is a page published in Batman Annual #25. This issue, which was related to Jason's 2000s return, shows Batman with Jason, who here is still alive. This page was included in a reprint of the Death in The Family story claiming to be "[...]an alternative final page for the lost chapter of A DEATH IN THE FAMILY in case the fans decided to save Robin[...] not see[ing] print until the release of Batman Annual #25". However, some believe that this scene was crafted well after the fact to kill the endless rumors.

Comments


avatar

Where'sFreaky

13 months ago
Score 0++

the Image is from Batman Annual #25, the issue talks about Red Hood (Jason Todd). Basicly in the issue he comes back to life after timelines collide due to Superman. It's just a random page in the issue. I don't know if that was the comic you were speaking off when you wrote "In an annual comic tied to Jason's 2000's return", but yeah, the image is taken out of context. That page has also been featured as an 'alternative ending' in the 2011 re-publican of Death in the family, (a clear image of it here: https://comi...ce-of-dying/).

We can bust the image as being the orginal alt ending, but lets hope we can find the real one! (if it's real)
avatar

Mightymessymatriarch

9 months ago
Score 0++
Thanks for pointing that out, but if you look at the image of the page, it says "jim aparo and mike decarlo drew an alternative final page for the lost chapter of A DEATH IN THE FAMILY in case the fans decided to save robin. It did not see print until the release of batman annual #25". So if that image is to be believed, THAT is the alternative ending.
avatar

Mightymessymatriarch

9 months ago
Score 0++
But it is possible that it was originally just a part of a different story, and THEN changed to say that it was a alternative ending. If thats the case then WOW DC Comic is pathetic.
avatar

Anonymous user #1

2 months ago
Score 0++
Check out the first episode of Mark Hamill's Pop Culture Quest, he takes a tour of the DC vaults and stops to check out this item. While they don't show too much more aside from the iconic page above, they do talk about it some more.
avatar

Regularshowman

1 months ago
Score 0++
Batman's face in the annual is way too happy for someone near death, lol.
Add your comment
The Lost Media Wiki welcomes all comments. If you do not want to be anonymous, register or log in. It is free.


This site is best viewed at 1920x1080 screen resolution.
Powered by MediaWiki Creative Commons Licence