Doom (lost prototype of Sega Saturn port of first-person shooter; 1996-1997)
Doom was a first-person-shooter developed by id Software in 1993. The game helped pioneer the concept of fps in video games, and stands as one of the most important video games of all time. With that, Doom would receive several console ports throughout the years, with some that were successful while others weren't.
A Sega Saturn port was developed by Rage Software and released by GT Interactive in the U.S. on March 26, 1997, much later than the competition, and even then, it is believed to have been rushed in development. A port of the PlayStation version with several features omitted and abysmal framerate, averaging at 13 frames per second, The Sega Saturn port of Doom is highly regarded as one of the worst ports of a game ever released, if not the most disappointing of them all.
Rumors were spread for many years that the Japanese release of Doom on Sega Saturn runs smoother than the North American release, however, in recent years, John Lineman of Digital Foundry debunked these rumors, with both NTSC-U and NTSC-J versions’ being virtually the same, framerate-wise.
Jim Bagley’s Prototype
The Sega Saturn port was originally meant to be an entirely unique project, unrelated to the PlayStation and Jaguar ports of Doom, the latter of which being the foundation for most of the console ports at the time, including the PlayStation version. Rage Software’s original goal was to port the original PC release of Doom and Doom II, with the levels of both games intact and without any changes related to hardware restrictions.
The lead programmer of the Saturn port of Doom, Jim Bagley, wrote a custom engine based on Doom’s idTech1 game engine which made full use of the Sega Saturn’s hardware. Despite the console being known for not handling 3D graphics as well as the PlayStation or the Nintendo 64, this custom engine was meant to be hardware-accelerated, making use of the Saturn’s graphics chips: the VDP1 for sprites and walls, and the VDP2 for background graphics. Bagley affirms that the game could run at 60FPS, a very rare feat in 3D Saturn games, let alone first-person shooters, and it could run at fullscreen on stock Saturn hardware.
The prototype was sent to id Software for approval. Even with the feats achieved by Jim Bagley, id founder John Carmack was unsatisfied with the prototype, telling Bagley to re-write the entire code to run in software mode, therefore using solely the CPU to run the game, to prevent affine texture warping, a quirk from 32-bit consoles like the Saturn and the PlayStation which Carmack hated. Due to time constraints, the idea of Rage Software porting the original PC release’s maps onto the Saturn Doom port was scrapped in favor of porting the PlayStation version, instead. The maps on the PlayStation port were derivative from the Atari Jaguar version, and were modified to accommodate the console’s restrictions. However, the Saturn’s architecture was too complex to do a competent port of PlayStation Doom in a short period of time, thus the final product being shipped with the low framerate. Several features of the PlayStation port of Doom were removed for the Sega Saturn port such as colored lighting, reverberation, and in the case of the NTSC release, deathmatch and co-op multiplayer. The PAL release received the removed game modes, however.
Status and Aftermath
Though some footage of beta versions of the Sega Saturn port of Doom can be seen online, nothing related to Jim Bagley’s prototype has surfaced. In 2016 on the DoomWorld forums, Bagley himself confirmed that he no longer owns the source code of the prototype nor the Saturn development kit which he used to program the game. It is unlikely that the prototype is saved at id Software’s archives, either.
On April 19th, 2020, Hidden Palace user Segafreak NL uploaded a ROM file of a build dated April 10th, 1996. While not much info is given, it's pointed out that the sound effects from this build are taken from the PC version of Doom, rather than the PlayStation version. While this doesn't indicate that it's tied to Jim Bagley's prototype, this could imply that at some point Rage Software's intention was to port the PlayStation version whilst making it look closer to the PC version in terms of presentation.
Despite his distaste for affine textures, John Carmack later admitted that he should’ve allowed more experiments with the Saturn hardware, in retrospect.
- Doom (lost FMV scenes and original work of 3DO port of first-person shooter game; 1994-1995)
- Doom (lost reference photographs for first-person shooter game cover art; 1993)
- Doom (partially found production materials of cancelled first-person shooter game film adaptations; 1994-1999)
- Doom and Doom 2 (partially lost original sound files of first-person shooter series audio; 1993-1994)
- Doom 4 (lost build of cancelled sequel based on "Doom" first-person shooter series; 2007-2014)
- Doom Absolution (lost build of cancelled Nintendo 64 sequel to "Doom 64"; 1997)
- Doom "Episode 5" (lost build of cancelled expansion to first-person shooter; 1995)
- A Digital Foundry YouTube video testing all ports of Doom (timestamped). Retrieved 21 Feb '19
- Episode 14 of The Retro Hour Podcast featuring Jim Bagley which talks about the Sega Saturn port prototype. (timestamped). Retrieved 21 Feb '19
- DoomWiki's article about Doom for the Sega Saturn.Retrieved 21 Feb '19
- SegaRetro's article about Doom for the Sega Saturn. Retrieved 21 Feb '19
- Jim Bagley's post on DoomWorld Forums. Retrieved 21 Feb '19
- Doom's April 10th 1996 build, from Hidden Palace Retrieved, 19 Apr '21
- John Carmack's tweet about the prototype. Retrieved 21 Feb '19