Aladdin (found Howard Ashman treatment of Disney animated film; 1988)
Composer Alan Menken (left) and writer Howard Ashman (right); c. late 1970s.
Date found: 14 Aug 2017
Found by: Anonymous
Originally pitched as an animated film by producer and lyricist Howard Ashman to Walt Disney Studios, the story of Aladdin went through many different hands between 1987 and its final release in 1992, resulting in many different scripts, outlines, and treatments. However, the most famous and sought-after treatment is Ashman's original 1988 treatment.
As he began work on Disney's upcoming feature The Little Mermaid, writer and lyricist Howard Ashman pitched an idea of a possible new animated feature to the studio, and in January 1988, he turned in a 40-page treatment of Aladdin, featuring a complete score, with lyrics by him and music by his frequent collaborator Alan Menken. Though the head of Disney animation at the time called it the best treatment he had ever read, Disney passed on it, and as per Ashman's contract, the company owned both the treatment and the score.
Soon after, the story was handed off to writer Linda Woolverton, and, once his work on Mermaid was nearing completion, Ashman, along with Menken, was brought in by studio chairman Jeffrey Katzenberg to save the troubled Beauty and the Beast production.
Chosen as a follow up to Mermaid by directors John Musker and Ron Clements, the duo looked through everything that had already been done for Aladdin and decided to combine the best aspects off all the different drafts and treatments, as well as adding more animation friendly characters (namely Abu the monkey and Rajah the tiger), and began working on a new draft of the script. Around this time, it was decided that Ashman and Menken's original score would be used when possible with the duo coming on board to write new material when needed. Also around this time, as Musker and Clements were preparing to fly out to New York (where Ashman lived), Ashman told Musker during a phone call;
"I just want to let you know before you come out here… I’ve been ill."
(Ashman, who had been diagnosed in 1988 as HIV positive, was beginning to show signs of his illness.) Due to this, the directors, along with producer Don Ernst, flew over and visited Ashman whenever possible to make sure he was involved. Ashman died from complications due to AIDS on March 14th, 1991, after completing a few new songs with Menken. Around the same time, the storyboard reel was shown to Jeffery Katzenberg, who told Musker and Clements afterward;
"I was so disengaged that all through the movie, I was working on the guest list for my wife’s surprise birthday party!"
With the fate of the film in jeopardy, Musker and Clements brought on writers Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio to rewrite the script yet again. Due to this, various story elements were cut or streamlined, resulting in further cuts to Ashman and Menken's score. To fill in the holes now left in the score, Menken wrote various songs by himself, before lyricist Tim Rice was hired to complete the final film score with him.
All story problems were successfully worked out by the film's release date of November 25th, 1992.
Status and Revivals
According to Ashman's sister, Sarah Ashman Gillespie, after production was halted on her brother's original draft, he thought about
"getting the rights back from Disney [...] and doing something along the lines of Shelley Duvall’s brilliant 'Faerie Tale Theater' with it."
However, these plans were abandoned, possibly due to Disney's continued work on the property,
In July 2011, a musical theatre version of Aladdin premiered in Seattle, Washington, at the 5th Avenue Theatre. Though restoring much of Ashman's original vision and score, cuts and changes between the show's original production and 2014 Broadway production resulted in various other cuts and edits. For these, writer and lyricist Chad Beguelin supplied the show with new lyrics.
On August 14th, 2017, LMW founder Dycaite received an anonymous email containing a copy of Howard Ashman's treatment in its entirety, available for download here.
The treatment is also available for viewing at the Library of Congress, as a part of the Howard Ashman papers, with another copy likely remaining in the Disney Animation Research Library. In addition to the treatment, the Library of Congress also houses several scripts for the film, including two from 1988, mere months after the initial treatment, likely meaning they are actually based on Ashman's original treatment, before the film was put on hold and then reworked. These scripts are available for any member of the public to read in person and get scanned to digital files for their own research purposes, but they are not available for free online reading, and they can't be scanned remotely without either permission from the Ashman estate or hiring an independent researcher to get them scanned in the same way any visitor can.
Parts of Howard Ashman's original script treatment for Aladdin was shown in Disney Plus' original documentary film Howard released on August 7th, 2020, when discussing his early involvement in creating music for the film.
In the original story, originally set in Baghdad, there were two genies: The Genie of the Ring - who would serve as the film's narrator appear from time to time to comment on and explain various points of the story - and The Genie of the Lamp. Aladdin is actually not an adult; instead, he is about fifteen years old and is motivated by the need to prove to his mother that he is responsible, capable of growing up and making her proud. Babkak, Omar, and Kasim are Aladdin’s gang of friends. Jafar was not "Jafar" yet; instead, he was called The Wazir, and his "smart-mouthed, back-talking sidekick" parrot was named Sinbad.
However, most surprising is the description of Jasmine as “ a purely comic creation; the ultimate in pampered spoiled brattiness” as well as the character Abbi:
"The tomboy female component in Aladdin’s gang. (In West Side Story she’d play ‘Anybody’s.’) She’s the Girl-Next-Door to Aladdin, and he doesn’t even notice that she is a girl until fairly late in the proceedings. But when he does notice, boy are we happy."
The original love story of the film would be as follows:
"While on an epic adventure to save the princess, Aladdin would see Abbi’s love for him manifested as she protects him on his journey. Though he is offered the princess’ hand in marriage after saving her life and the kingdom, Aladdin ultimately refuses in favor of true love with Abbi."
Only two songs from Ashman and Menken's original score remain in the final movie: "Arabian Nights", and "Friend Like Me".
- Arabian Nights: Written to be sung by The Genie of the Ring, who was to be the narrator of the film, it was meant to introduce the setting and tone of the film. Though making the final film, much like The Little Mermaid's "Fathom's Below", it would be cut down, losing roughly two choruses, a verse, and a bridge section in the process. The first direct-to-video sequel used the unused second verse as the basis for its own version of Arabian Nights, and the stage musical would revive almost the entire Ashman-written version. The 2019 film would then revive the complete song's structure and reuse some cut lyrics, though songwriting team Benj Pasek and Justin Paul would be brought on to contribute original lyrics.
- Arabian Nights - Reprise #1*: To be sung by Genie of the Ring and meant to introduce The Wazir. (These reprises of Arabian Nights -- save for the third, which would be replaced by a new, original one -- would later be used in the Seattle and Vancouver productions of the stage musical, sung by Babkak, Omar, and Kassim, though they would be cut after these preview shows)
- Babkak, Omar, Aladdin, Kassim: To be sung by, and meant to introduce, Aladdin and his friends, Babkak, Omar, and Kassim. (Revived for the stage play)
- Arabian Nights - Reprise #2*: To be sung by Genie of the Ring as The Wazir leads Aladdin to The Cave of Wonders.
- Friend Like Me: To be sung by Genie of the Lamp as Aladdin becomes his master. This song would make it to the final film, earning Ashman and Menken their final Oscar nomination together.
- Proud of Your Boy: To be sung by Aladdin to his mother. Though included when production on the film was fully revived, it was cut around the time of Ashman's death. The rough storyboard and demo to the song was included on the film's 2004 Platinum Edition release, along with a recording of the song by singer Clay Aiken. The sing was restored to the stage musical.
- Call Me a Princess: Sung by Princess Jasmine, a "purely comic" character, after she hears her maids gossiping about her behind her back. The song was reworked by Chad Beguelin for the original Seattle and Toronto productions of the musical, where she uses the song to scare away potential suitors. However, the song was again cut for the Broadway run, replaced by "These Palace Walls."
- How Quick They Forget*: To be sung by Babkak, Omar, and Kassim after Aladdin abandons them while trying to gain the love of the princess.
- Arabian Nights - Reprise #3*: To be sung by the Genie of the Ring, after Aladdin has been imprisoned, the Sultan falsely believing he was in cahoots with the Wazir.
- High Adventure: To be sung by the Genie of the Ring, Aladdin, Abbi, Babkak, Omar, and Kassim as the group goes to save Princess Jasmine. (This song would be revived for the stage play)
- Arabian Nights - Reprise #4: To be sung by the Genie of the Ring at the end of the film as the finale, as Aladdin, Abbi, and their friends get their happy endings. (Recorded but cut from the final film, and used for Aladdin and the King of Thieves. Though not fully used, the musical's finale is based on this reprise.)
- *indicates that song was not restored in the Broadway production of the stage musical adaptation.
Along with the songs listed above, Ashman and Menken wrote other songs for Aladdin, not included in the original score, including:
- The Wazir's Song: To be sung by Jafar / The Wazir and his parrot Sinbad as they're unmasking Prince Ali. Listed on the Aladdin Central website, the lyrics are supposedly from the July 15, 1990, draft of the script and written by Ashman. With what appears to be rough, unfinished lyrics, it's possible that "The Wazir's Song" is Ashman's rough sketch for "Humiliate the Boy" or placeholder lyrics by Musker and/or Clements.
- Prince Ali: Sung by the Genie of the Lamp (now the only Genie in the film), the song was written by Ashman and Menken. The song would ultimately be cut down slightly for the movie, removing an intro section and a verse, though the cut sections would be restored for the stage musical.
- Humiliate The Boy: Sung by Jafar and his parrot, now re-named Iago, it was to take place when Jafar takes over control of Agrabah and unmasks "Prince Ali". This would be the final song Ashman and Menken wrote for the film, as well as their final collaboration altogether. Jonathan Freeman recorded two demos of the song, using the same instrumentation and lyrics, but a very different delivery.
- The Incredibles (found full version of McDonald's Happy Meal commercial for Pixar animated film; 2004)
- The Incredibles (found online promotional trailers for Pixar animated film; 2004)
- Pixar (partially lost early CGI animated commercials from animation studio; 1989-1998)
- Alice in Wonderland (partially lost original draft of Disney animated film; 1939)
- American Dog (partially found original version of "Bolt" Disney animated film; 2007-2008)
- The Black Cauldron (partially found deleted scenes of Disney animated film; 1985)
- Chanticleer (partially found production material of cancelled Disney animated film; 1940s-mid 1960s)
- Chicken Little 2 (partially found production material of cancelled sequel to Disney animated comedy film; 2006)
- Disney Circle Seven Animation (partially lost production material of cancelled Pixar sequel films; 2004-2006)
- Dumbo II (partially found production material from cancelled Disney animated sequel film; 2000s)
- Fantasia 2006 (partially lost production material for cancelled Disney animated sequel film; 2002-2004)
- Fraidy Cat (lost production material of cancelled Disney animated film; 2004-2005)
- Frozen (partially found early drafts of Disney animated film; 1937-2012)
- Gigantic (lost production material of cancelled Disney animated film; 2013-2017)
- The Jungle Book (lost Bill Peet version of Disney animated film; 1963-1964)
- Kingdom of the Sun (partially found original version of "The Emperor's New Groove" Disney animated film; late 1990s)
- The Lion King II: Simba's Pride (partially found production material and deleted scenes of Disney animated sequel film; 1995-1998)
- Maleficent (lost production material of cancelled Disney animated film; 2003-2005)
- Music Land (lost Disney animated anthology film; 1955)
- My Peoples (partially found production material of cancelled Disney animated film; late 1990s-early 2000s)
- The Search for Mickey Mouse (lost production material of cancelled Disney animated film; 2002)
- The Seven Dwarfs (partially found production material of cancelled direct-to-video prequel to "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs" Disney animated film; 2000s)
- Tangled (partially found early drafts of Disney animated film; 2001-2010)
- Tinker Bell (partially found first draft of Disney animated film; 2007)
- Treasure Planet II (lost production material of cancelled Disney animated sequel film; 2002)
- Wild Life (lost production material for cancelled Disney animated film; late 1990s-2000)
- Zootopia (partially found pre-rewrite version of Disney animated film; early 2010s)
- A Tin Toy Christmas (lost production material of cancelled Pixar animated Christmas TV special; early 1990s)
- Cars 3 (lost deleted scene of Pixar animated sequel film; 2017)
- The Good Dinosaur (lost original version of Pixar animated film; 2011-2013)
- Inside Out (lost original Bing Bong death scene of Pixar animated film; 2015)
- Made in Point Richmond (found miscellaneous content from Pixar DVD; 1986-2000)
- Newt (partially found production material of cancelled Pixar animated film; early 2010s)
- Toy Story (partially found early test footage of Pixar animated film; 1992)
- Toy Story 4 (found original script of Pixar animated sequel film; 2013-2017)
- Toy Story & Toy Story 2 (partially found intermissions for 3D double feature re-release of Pixar animated films; 2009)
- Toy Story "Black Friday Reel" (partially found rough cut of Pixar animated film; 1993)
- Toy Story "Jessie" (found Patsy Montana Award acceptance speech animation of Pixar character; 2000)
- WALL·E (partially found original treatments of Pixar animated film; 1994-2008)
- Enchanted (lost deleted song from Disney live-action/animated fantasy comedy film; 2007)
- Fantasia (partially lost original audio of Disney animated film; 1940)
- Jack Wagner (partially lost Disney Park background music collection from American actor; 1970s-2001)
- Mars Needs Moms (found Seth Green vocal performance of Disney motion-capture animated film; 2011)
- The Nightmare Before Christmas (lost original Vincent Price audio of Disney stop-motion animated film; early 1990s)
- Pinocchio (lost Mel Blanc's "Gideon the Cat" dialogue from Disney animated film; 1940)
- Toy Story 2 (partially found Bullseye dialogue test footage from Pixar animated sequel film; late 1990s)
- 101 Dalmatians (found "Spotted Landmarks" teaser trailer of Disney live-action film; 1995-1996)
- Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey (found deleted scenes from Disney live-action film; 1993)
- Sleeping Beauty (partially found live action reference material for Disney animated film; 1959)
- Something Wicked This Way Comes (lost original cut of Disney dark fantasy film; 1982)
- Walt Disney (lost physical Mickey Mouse animation reference footage of animator; late 1930s)
- Alice Comedies (partially lost series of Walt Disney animated short films; 1920s)
- Blowin' in the Wind (found Pixar animated short film; 1985)
- Lafflets (lost series of Walt Disney animated short films; 1922-1923)
- Language Arts Through Imagination (found series of Disney educational short films; 1988-1989)
- Mickey and Minnie Mouse (lost unauthorized pornographic animated short film; existence unconfirmed; 1936)
- Mickey's Man Friday (partially found production material of unproduced remake of Disney animated short film; 1939-1941)
- Oswald the Lucky Rabbit (partially lost series of Walt Disney animated short films; 1927-1928)
- Poor Papa (found "Oswald the Lucky Rabbit" Walt Disney animated short film; 1927)
- The Princess Academy (lost production material of cancelled Disney animated short film; 2009)
- Short Subject aka "Mickey Mouse in Vietnam" (found unofficial animated short film; 1968)
- Tales from Radiator Springs "To Protect and Serve" (lost episode of "Cars" animated miniseries; 2015)
- Totally Twisted Fairy Tales (partially found Disney animated short series; 1997)
- Uncle Walt (lost unauthorized Disney short film; 1964)
- ↑ "Aladdin, The Tonys and More", Part of His World - Howard Ashman, Sarah Ashman-Gillespie. Retrieved 31 Jan '16
- ↑ Aladdin: In Our Collections and Now on Broadway! - Library of Congress. Retrieved 31 Jan '16
- ↑ "John Musker Question Countdown – Number 9", Part of His World - Howard Ashman, John Musker. Retrieved 31 Jan '16
- ↑ "Critic Critique", Part of His World - Howard Ashman, Sarah Ashman-Gillespie. Retrieved 31 Jan '16
- ↑ Howard Ashman papers catalog listing - Library of Congress - pg. 7. Retrieved 31 Jan '16
- ↑ Howard Ashman papers finding aid - Library of Congress - pg. 1. Retrieved 03 Jan '20
- ↑ Disney+'s page on Howard (requires a subscription to view the film). Retrieved 07 Aug '20
- ↑ "The Wazir Song" - Cut Song Lyrics - Aladdin Central. Retrieved 31 Jan '16